Welton Academy is a strict private school rich fathers send their sons to in order to prepare them for their following education as doctors and lawyers. Their daily routine is dictated by the school's four pillars tradition, honor, discipline and excellence and everything nonacademic is deemed as unnecessary and is punished severely. Mr Keating, the new English teacher, however challenges them to life their lifes as fully as possible and inspires a group of boys to resurrect the Dead poets society, a club with its origin during the time Mr Keating went to Welton Academy. The boys have to realize the tragic consequences their new-found freedom and individuality will have soon or their hopes and dreams will be brutally destroyed by the authorities.
"We don't read and write poetry because it's cute. We read and write poetry because we are members of the human race. And the human race is filled with passion. So medicine, law, business, engineering... these are noble pursuits and necessary to sustain life. But poetry, beauty, romance, love... these are what we stay alive for."
I read this book with my English class in school, which led to a few reasons that caused me to enjoy this novel a lot less than I would've enjoyed it if I just read it by myself. First of all, it took us over a month to finally finish it and because of that the whole reading process felt super unsatisfying for me since I literally could've read it in two hours. Also, some of my lovely class mates spoiled the only kind of shocking event for me thereby making the book even more boring and predictable than it already was. Obviously I wasn't expecting a really intense and exciting story when I started this book, but I wasn't even close to being prepared for such a dull and dreary storyline. Nothing happens for the first 70 pages and, considering that the novel only has a bit less than 170 pages in total, that's a pretty big part of the book. When the story finally picks up the pace, it just gets weirder. Suddenly the book is going into a completely different direction for the next 20 pages and after that it goes back to normal as if nothing ever happened. The story in general felt kind of unbalanced to me since the different plot lines don't really affect each other and the book tends to focus on one character's point of view for way too long. Most of the time when the POV changes, it's so sudden and abrupt, which confused me a lot. Something that completely perplexed me as well are these random and unnecessary remarks that are everywhere in this novel. Even worse, some of them are unintentionally hilarious, which just makes the book seem pretty ridiculous. The only thing I really enjoyed about the plot is the ending because it does complete the story in a lovely, even moving way, especially by bringing up a scene from the very beginning of the book again. Another aspect I quite liked is the big role that poetry plays in the story and even though I did skim through most of the poems or even skipped some completely, the few I read, mainly the ones the main characters came up with, actually managed to inspire me and I ended up really enjoying them. The writing is quite good, you can obviously see that it was written about 25 years ago but that honestly didn't bother me at all. However, one thing that I got a little bit mad about when I found out, is the fact that the book is based on the movie and not the other way around like it usually is (and supposed to be), so I definitely lost some respect for the author as well as the novel.
I had a lot of issues with the characters as well. None of them, except for Todd, Mr Keating and maybe Neil, really stood out to me, so at the end of the novel I still had no clue who the hell Meeks is and didn't even realize there is someone called Cameron in it until everybody started hating on him. Whoops. All the characters are either really boring, for example Neil and Meeks, or really annoying, like Knox and Charlie. For me the most interesting character is Todd because he's seriously the only one to go through some sort of development, which I actually quite enjoyed, and I also feel like I understand his struggles as a shy and introverted character pretty good. The friendships between the boys are decent, they're nothing special, but they add a nice atmosphere to the book. Even though it seemed a bit unusual for me at first, simply because we have a completely different contact with our teachers, the bond between Mr Keating and the boys is lovely and in very few scenes even empowering. The big romantic relationship in this book however is just horrible and so cringeworthy. Everything about it just feels forced and wrong since they don't fit together in my opinion.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but we'll definitely watch it in class soon and even though it's quite old, I'm still looking forward to it and I'm quite hopeful it'll be more enjoyable than the book.
Rating: 2/5 ✹
I hope you enjoyed this review. Have a wonderful day!
Leah